A St Valentine’s day kiss and make up between Manchester City and Carlos Tevez

However, this is one relationship headed for heart-break and tears.

Just when Man City’s PR and marketing professionals should be building their brand, the toxic nature of this story threatens to undermine all their efforts.

To recap, striker Carlos Tevez refused to play for City in a match at the end of the year. Cue a bitter fall-out between player and club and a parting of the ways seemed inevitable.

Only one problem with that .. no other club wanted to buy him in the January transfer window.

So here we are in February and, miraculously, both parties have had a dramatic change of heart. The player wants to return to help City try and win the Barclays Premier League title – and the club are delighted to have him back in the fold.

If only City had been strong enough to banish Tevez into exile (or the reserves at any rate), they could have done wonders for their brand. Their stance would have said that petulance won’t be tolerated and their values are more important than any individual player.

A position which would have been welcomed all over the world.

In a week when Liverpool Football Club – one of the strongest brands in world sport – had their reputation tarnished by one of their players, Luis Suarez, refusing to shake hands with an opponent on the back of a racism row, Manchester City could have taken a position which showed that they had standards which they wanted to uphold.

By welcoming Tevez back into the fold, they don’t demonstrate forgiveness and understanding.

They simply show that the financial imperative and clamour for success overrides any other consideration.

Filed under: ,
  • Steve Earl

    Amen to that final sentence (says a United fan..).

    But City’s main failing here is failing to engage in any conversation about why Tevez is back. Even his teammates haven’t been let in on it apparently. So unless there’s some clear and frank communication on that front soon, I imagine it’s an issue that will fester and while he might get back to scoring goals it could unsettle the rest of the team.

    Perhaps ‘my’ lot should start clearing room in the bulging cabinet for another top-flight trophy :-)

  • Most discussed/rated

  • Tags

  • Authors

  • Archive

    February 2012
    M T W T F S S
    « Jan   Mar »
     12345
    6789101112
    13141516171819
    20212223242526
    272829  
Powered by WordPress. Built on the Thematic Theme Framework.
PR Week. The leading source of news, insight and analysis on the Public Relations Industry